How to Fix a Leaky Toilet Tank: Find the Cause

A leaking toilet tank can waste water, damage flooring, or leave a puddle around the base. The repair depends on where the water is coming from: water inside the bowl often points to a flapper that is not sealing, while water outside the tank may come from a connection, bolt, or crack. Start by drying everything and tracing the leak rather than tightening parts at random.

What You’ll Need

Adjustable wrench or pliers
Sponge or towels and a small container
Replacement flapper, fill valve, or tank-to-bowl bolt kit, as needed
Flashlight and, optionally, food coloring
Gloves, if you prefer them for handling tank water

Take a photo of the tank’s internal parts before removing anything. Toilet parts vary, so use the toilet or component manufacturer’s instructions when available. Do not use a wrench on plastic nuts unless the instructions say to; hand-tightening is often enough.

Step-by-Step

Shut off the supply. Find the shutoff valve on the wall or floor behind the toilet and turn it clockwise until it stops. If it will not turn or begins leaking, do not force it; shut off the home’s main water supply if you know how, then get help. Avoid overtightening an old valve.
Empty and dry the tank. Remove the lid carefully and set it on a stable, protected surface. Flush once to lower the water, then sponge out what remains if you need a dry working area. Keep the tank lid upright and secure; ceramic lids can break easily.
Locate the leak. Dry the tank exterior, supply line, valve, and floor. Turn the water on briefly and watch with a flashlight, then shut it off again if water appears. Check the supply-line connection, the fill valve where it passes through the tank, the tank bolts, and the seam between tank and bowl. Water inside the bowl without an exterior drip may be a flapper leak. A few drops after flushing may be condensation, not a leak; wipe the tank and see whether moisture returns in a distinct trail.
Check for a flapper leak. With the tank full and the supply on, add a few drops of food coloring to the tank water without flushing. If color appears in the bowl after about 10 to 15 minutes, water is passing the flush valve. Turn off the supply and remove the old flapper from the overflow tube or hinge arms. Take it to a hardware store or match its shape and attachment style. Install the replacement, reconnect the chain, and leave a little slack: it should lift fully when flushed but not hold the flapper open.
Adjust or replace the fill valve if water overflows. Look at the overflow tube. If water keeps running into it, the tank water level may be too high or the fill valve may not shut off. Use the valve’s adjustment mechanism to set the waterline to the marked line inside the tank, or roughly an inch below the top of the overflow tube if there is no mark. Follow the valve instructions. If adjustment does not stop the flow, replace the fill valve using its instructions; close the supply, drain the tank, disconnect the supply line, and remove the valve’s retaining nut. Reconnect without twisting the valve or cross-threading its plastic nut.
Address a leak at a tank bolt or seal. If water drips from a tank bolt or the tank-to-bowl seam, shut off the water and empty the tank. Tightening a bolt slightly and evenly may help, but do not crank down on ceramic. If it still leaks, replace the bolt washers or the tank-to-bowl gasket with a compatible kit. The tank usually must be lifted off the bowl, so get assistance if it is awkward or heavy. Fit washers in the order specified by the kit; bolt designs differ.
Check the supply connection. If water forms at the hose connection, shut off the valve and gently tighten the connection by hand, then use a wrench only for a small additional adjustment if needed. Do not overtighten. Replace a damaged hose or washer rather than trying to seal it with tape; follow the connector instructions and keep the line straight.
Restore water and test. Open the shutoff valve slowly. Let the tank fill, then flush several times while watching each connection and the tank-to-bowl seam. Dry the exterior and check again after 10 to 15 minutes. Confirm the tank stops filling at the correct level and that the bowl does not receive a steady trickle.

Common Mistakes

Overtightening bolts: Ceramic can crack under pressure. Tighten tank bolts evenly and only enough to stop a leak; replace failed washers or seals instead of forcing the hardware.
Buying the wrong part: Flappers and fill valves are not all interchangeable. Check the part’s shape, connection, and compatibility with your toilet before installation.
Leaving the chain too tight: A taut chain can keep the flapper from sealing. Leave slight slack while ensuring the handle still lifts it fully.
Ignoring a slow leak: A tank can silently send water into the bowl even when the floor is dry. Use the dye test and listen for periodic refilling.
Sealing the wrong place: Caulk or adhesive is not a repair for a cracked tank, failed gasket, or leaking connection. It can conceal the source and complicate a proper repair.

Tips

Change one part at a time so you can tell which repair fixed the problem.
Keep the old part until the replacement is installed and tested; it can help identify the correct style.
Use manufacturer instructions for fill-valve height, water-level adjustment, and washer order.
If the shutoff valve is stiff, corroded, or leaking, do not force it. A plumber can replace it safely.
Check the floor and nearby wall after the repair. Water can travel along a hose or tank surface and drip somewhere other than the source.

Troubleshooting

The bowl still gets colored water: Check that the flapper is the right type, sits flat, and is not obstructed by the chain. Clean mineral deposits from the flush-valve seat with a nonabrasive cloth. If the seat is damaged or warped, the flush valve may need repair or replacement.

The fill valve keeps running: Confirm that the float moves freely and the waterline is below the overflow tube. If the valve is correctly adjusted but continues to run, replace it. Also check that the refill tube is clipped above the overflow opening, not pushed down into it.

A tank bolt still drips: Stop tightening. Drain the tank and inspect the washers for incorrect placement, damage, or a mismatched kit. If the tank has a hairline crack near a bolt or seam, replace the tank rather than attempting a patch.

Water appears only on the tank exterior: In humid conditions, condensation can form when cold refill water cools the tank. Dry the surface and see whether drops form evenly over a broad area rather than tracing from a joint. If the water returns at one fitting or seam, treat it as a leak.

The leak is at the base of the toilet: That is generally not a tank repair. Stop using the toilet if water continues to escape, dry the area, and contact a plumber; the bowl seal or another connection may be involved.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use the toilet while the tank is leaking?

If the leak is small and contained, you can shut off the supply between uses, but avoid using the toilet if water is reaching the floor or damaging nearby materials. A leak at the base needs prompt attention.

How do I know whether the flapper is the problem?

Use the food-coloring test: color that moves from the tank into the bowl without flushing indicates water is passing the flush-valve seal. Check the flapper’s fit and chain before replacing it.

Should I use plumber’s tape on tank bolts?

No. Tank bolts seal with their rubber washers, not thread tape. Use the correct washers and hardware, and tighten cautiously to protect the porcelain.

Can a cracked toilet tank be repaired?

A cracked tank should generally be replaced. Adhesives and sealants are unreliable for a tank holding water and can hide a worsening crack; stop using it if the crack is leaking.

When should I call a plumber?

Call if a shutoff valve will not operate, the porcelain is cracked, the leak persists after replacing the relevant part, or you cannot safely lift the tank. Also seek help if water is leaking from the toilet base or into the floor.

Further reading: This Old House. Details can change, so check the official page for anything that matters to you. Spotted a mistake? Tell us. How we write an answer.