02Home & Garden · Updated
Birds That Avoid Safflower Seeds (and Why)
Short answer
House sparrows, European starlings, and most blackbirds avoid safflower seeds
Safflower seeds have a bitter taste and a hard shell that many common nuisance birds dislike, while cardinals, chickadees, and finches readily eat them.
Why Safflower Seeds Are Different
Safflower seeds come from a plant grown mostly for oil, but the seeds are also sold as bird food. They look like small, white, elongated sunflower seeds. The key difference is the bitter taste, which comes from natural compounds in the seed coat. Many birds that happily eat sunflower seeds will reject safflower because of that bitterness. The shell is also harder than a sunflower seed’s, so birds with weaker beaks may struggle to crack it open.
This bitterness is a built-in deterrent. It doesn’t harm the birds—they just don’t like the flavor. So if you want to feed birds without attracting certain species, safflower is a clever choice.
Which Birds Skip Safflower Seeds?
The birds that most often avoid safflower are the same ones that can dominate a feeder and scare off other birds:
- House sparrows – These small brown birds are common at feeders but generally turn up their beaks at safflower.
- European starlings – Known for aggressive feeding habits, they usually avoid safflower because of the taste and texture.
- Blackbirds – Red-winged blackbirds, common grackles, and cowbirds typically pass on safflower.
- Pigeons and doves – Rock pigeons and mourning doves may eat safflower if hungry, but they don’t prefer it.
- Blue jays – While they can crack the shell, many jays don’t like the taste and will ignore it.
However, individual birds can be unpredictable. Some house sparrows or starlings may eventually develop a taste for safflower, especially if other food is scarce. So while safflower is a great deterrent, it’s not a 100% guarantee.
Who Eats Safflower Seeds?
On the flip side, many desirable backyard birds love safflower:
- Northern cardinals – These bright red birds are especially fond of safflower and will visit feeders that offer it.
- Chickadees – Black-capped and Carolina chickadees easily crack the shell and enjoy the nutty kernel.
- Titmice – Tufted titmice are regular visitors to safflower feeders.
- Finches – House finches, purple finches, and goldfinches will eat safflower, though they may prefer sunflower or nyjer.
- Nuthatches – White-breasted and red-breasted nuthatches can manage the hard shell.
- Woodpeckers – Downy, hairy, and red-bellied woodpeckers sometimes eat safflower, especially in winter.
If you want to attract cardinals and chickadees while discouraging house sparrows and starlings, safflower is a good choice.
How to Offer Safflower Seeds
You can serve safflower in several types of feeders:
- Hopper feeders – These hold a good amount and let cardinals perch comfortably.
- Tube feeders – Smaller birds like chickadees and finches can cling and feed.
- Platform or tray feeders – Cardinals and larger birds prefer open feeding areas.
- Mesh or sock feeders – Not ideal for safflower because the seeds are too large; stick to hopper or tube.
When switching to safflower, some birds may take a few days to recognize it as food. You can mix a small amount with sunflower seeds to help them adjust. Once they learn, they’ll come back regularly.
Keep the feeder clean and dry. Safflower seeds can sprout if they get wet, and moldy seeds can make birds sick. Empty and clean your feeders every couple of weeks, especially in humid weather.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
“Safflower seeds are poisonous” – False. Safflower is safe for birds and humans. The bitterness is just a taste preference, not a toxin.
“No birds will eat safflower” – Not true. Many birds love it, especially cardinals. The key is that some birds avoid it, which is exactly why people use it.
“Safflower attracts squirrels” – Squirrels will eat safflower if they’re hungry, but they don’t prefer it. Some people find it reduces squirrel visits, but it’s not a reliable squirrel deterrent.
“You need to crack the shells” – No, birds do that themselves. Safflower is sold whole, and birds with strong beaks handle it fine.
Safflower vs. Sunflower Seeds
Sunflower seeds (especially black-oil) are the most popular bird food because they attract a wide variety of species. Safflower is more selective. If you want to feed as many birds as possible, sunflower is better. If you want to discourage certain species, safflower is the way to go.
Some feeders mix both. This can be a good compromise: you get the variety of sunflower while still offering safflower for cardinals and other birds that prefer it. But if your goal is to keep starlings away, mixing defeats the purpose because they’ll eat the sunflower.
Cost and Availability
Safflower seeds are widely available at garden centers, hardware stores, and online. They are usually a bit more expensive than sunflower seeds, but not dramatically so. Because fewer birds eat them, a bag can last longer, which may offset the cost. Prices vary by brand and quantity, so shop around.
Safety and Storage
Safflower seeds are safe for birds, but you should store them properly to keep them fresh. Keep the bag in a cool, dry place, and seal it tightly to prevent moisture and pests. If you notice a musty smell or clumping, discard the seeds—they may be moldy.
Always wash your hands after handling birdseed, as it can contain dust or bacteria. And if you have pets, keep seeds out of their reach; while not toxic, large amounts can cause digestive upset.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will safflower seeds attract rats?
Like any birdseed, safflower can attract rodents if spilled on the ground. Use a tray or feeder with a catch to minimize waste, and clean up spilled seeds regularly.
Can I feed safflower seeds to my pet bird?
Yes, safflower seeds are safe for pet birds like parrots and canaries, but they are high in fat. Offer them as an occasional treat, not a staple. Consult your avian veterinarian for specific dietary advice.
Do safflower seeds go bad?
Safflower seeds can spoil if exposed to moisture or heat. They typically last several months when stored properly in a cool, dry place. If they smell rancid or show signs of mold, throw them out.
Why are the birds ignoring my safflower feeder?
It may take time for birds to discover a new food. Try mixing a little sunflower seed in to attract attention, and be patient. Also, ensure the feeder is clean and placed near cover where birds feel safe.
Do hummingbirds eat safflower seeds?
No, hummingbirds eat nectar and tiny insects, not seeds. Safflower is irrelevant to them.
Related
- Why Is My Lawn Sinking? Causes & Fixes
- Why Is My Lawn Not Growing? Causes & Fixes
- Why Do We Celebrate Constitution Day?
Further reading: Cornell Lab of Ornithology. Details can change, so check the official page for anything that matters to you. Spotted a mistake? Tell us. How we write an answer.